Alliance for Permanent Access News
25th June 2014, 15:00 CET, 2 pm UK time, 9 am East Coast US. The webinar is scheduled to last 2 hours.
Come and join the next APARSEN Webinar to learn about new interoperability solutions for Persistent Identifier systems for digital objects, authors and contributors. In the current Web environment, many initiatives have been launched for Persistent Identifiers and a variety of different communities are working with their own set of schemas and resolution services. For digital preservation it is of upmost importance that Persistent Identifiers schemes remain operable in the future and become interoperable among each other in order to ensure long-term accessibility, exchange and reuse of scientific and cultural data. In the Webinar experts will present different approaches to defragment the current situation and potential benefits for users of implementing services across PI domains and communities.
These results will feed into the Virtual Centre of Expertise network under development by the APARSEN project.
- Maurizio Lunghi & Emanuele Bellini, Fondazione Rinascimento Digitale: “A model for interoperability of PI systems and new services across domains“
- Sunje Dallmeier-Tiessen & Samuele Carli, CERN: “Implementation of persistent identifiers in a large scale digital library”
- Juha Hakala, Finnish National Library: “Revision of the URN standards and its implications to other PIDs”
- Anila Angjeli, Bibliotheque Nationale de France, ISNI consortium: “ISNI- abridge PID, a hub of links”
- Laure Haak, ORCID: “Connecting persistent identifiers for people, places, and things: ORCID as an information hub“
- Barbara Bazzanella, University of Trento: “The Entity Name System (ENS): a technical platform for implementing a Digital Identifier Interoperability Infrastructure”
- David Giaretta, APA: “The APARSEN Virtual Centre of Expertise”
Moderator: Eefke Smit (STM Association)
Further information about the event will be added shortly.
The meeting will be a web-meeting and will take place on megameeting.
Participation is free, no registration required!
Read more about previous APARSEN webinars here.
Workshop: Digital preservation sustainability on the EU policy level
Workshop in connection with Digital Libraries 2014
The Joint Conference on Digital Libraries (JCDL) and the International Conference on Theory and Practice of Digital Libraries (TPDL), London, United Kingdom, 8-12 September 2014
Date and Venue: 8th September 2014, London City University’s Northampton Square campus.
Duration: 13:00 to 17:00
Expected audience: Decision makers, managers, researcher, practitioners, librarians, publishers and their suppliers, developers, data managers
Expected number of attendees: Depending on available facilities
Registration: Registration for this workshop is free and must be completed by filling out the form here - http://bit.ly/DPSustainabilityObjectives for the workshop:
The main objective of the workshop is to provide an overview of solutions to challenges within Digital Preservation Sustainability developed by current and past Digital Preservation research projects. The event brings together various EU projects/initiatives to present their solutions and approaches, and to find synergies between them. A special focus will lie on SCAPE (Scalable Preservation Environments), which will have its final project presentation at this event.Description of the workshop:
The workshop co-organised by the FP7 projects SCAPE and APARSEN covers a wide spectrum of fields of expertise which are related to Sustainability and Digital Preservation. The workshop consists of two parts: 1) a panel discussion, and 2) a clinic.
In the opening panel session three experts from SCAPE, APARSEN and OPF will discuss the current status of Digital Preservation Sustainability on EU policy level. The aim of the panel discussion is to present, discuss, and evaluate main results of the projects and initiatives and how these will be sustained after the end of the projects. The attendees will have the opportunity to bring in their own questions related to Sustainability and Digital Preservation.
With real time visualization of the discussion by Elco van Staveren:
After the panel discussion the attendees can visit stalls run by invited Digital Preservation projects, where they can get information about the projects. Each project/initiative will run a stall and present their view on Digital Preservation sustainability in their particular field. In this “clinic” the projects / initiatives will act as ‘doctors’, so the visiting audience can discuss their preservation issues and get advice from experts.
As part of the workshop SCAPE will make its final, overall presentation, where the attendees have the possibility to meet many of the developers. The project team will present tools and services developed since the start of the project in 2011. A special focus will lie on newly and further developed open source tools for scalable preservation actions; SCAPE’s scalable platform architecture; and its policy-based Planning and Watch solutions.Programme
13:00-14:40 Panel Session (moderator: Hildelies Balk, NL)
13:00-13:15 APARSEN (Dr. David Giaretta, UK)
13:15-13:30 SCAPE (Dr. Ross King, AT)
13:30-13:45 OPF (Ed Fay, UK)
13:45-14:30 Panel discussion
14:30-14:40 Wrap up and Conclusions
14:40-14:50 Elevator Pitches
14:50-15:00 Short break
15:00-17:00 Clinic Session (all projects involved) – coffee during this session
Dr. David Giaretta, Director of Alliance for Permanent Access (APA),
David Giaretta gained his MA, MSc and a doctorate in Theoretical Physics from Oxford University. He has worked on a number of astronomical satellites, including the Hubble Space Telescope, ran a number of repositories of scientific data and has published numerous scientific articles. Dr. Giaretta chaired the panel which produced the original and led the update of OAIS Reference Model (ISO 14721). He led the production of the ISO standard (ISO 16363) for audit and certification of trustworthy digital repositories, and the creation of the certification process. In 2003 Dr. Giaretta was awarded an MBE for services to Space Science and 2012 the Emmett Leahy Award.
Dr. Ross King, Project Coordinator for SCAPE,
Ross King received his Ph.D. in physics from Stanford University. He is a Senior Scientist and Thematic Coordinator for Next Generation Content Management Systems at AIT Austrian Institute of Technology. Dr. King is Chairman of the Board of the Open Planets Foundation and the Coordinator of the FP7 digital preservation project SCAPE.
Ed Fay, Director of Open Planets Foundation (OPF),
Ed Fay is the Executive Director of the Open Planets Foundation. He has worked in digital cultural heritage for a decade developing approaches to digitisation, digital preservation, and online user experience. Prior to joining the Open Planets Foundation he led the introduction of a user-centred approach to digital library services at the London School of Economics and previously worked on several digitisation projects under JISC programmes in the UK. He holds an MA in Philosophy and an MSc in Information Science.
Hildelies Balk, Head of the section European Projects for Research and Development, National Library of the Netherlands, and involved in both APARSEN and SCAPE
Dr. Hildelies Balk – Pennington de Jongh MPM is Head of Research at the National Library of the Netherlands (KB). With her team she is responsible for Research and Development in digitisation, digital preservation and digital humanities. She was Coordinator and Scientific Director of the FP7 IMPACT project for innovative tools in OCR and language technology, and has been responsible for many other European and international projects over the years (PLANETS, KEEP, SCAPE, APARSEN, SUCCEED, e-MOP). She is a member of the Board of Directors of the Open Planets Foundation and Chair of the Executive board of the IMPACT Centre of Competence in digitisation (http://www.digitisation.eu/). Hildelies is an experienced leader of workshops on strategy development, business modelling and digital library topics. She holds a PhD in the History of Art and a MSc in Public Management with a special interest in open innovation.
Projects in the Clinic
APARSEN - Alliance Permanent Access to the Records of Science in Europe Network - is a Network of Excellence that brings together an extremely diverse set of practitioner organisations and researchers in order to bring coherence, cohesion and continuity to research into barriers to the long-term accessibility and usability of digital information and data, exploiting our diversity by building a long-lived Virtual Centre of Digital Preservation Excellence. The objective of this project may be simply stated, namely to look across the excellent work in digital preservation which is carried out in Europe and to try to bring it together under a common vision.
SCAPE - Scalable Preservation Environments – develops scalable services for planning and execution of institutional preservation strategies on an open source platform that orchestrates semi-automated workflows for large-scale, heterogeneous collections of complex digital objects. SCAPE enhances the state of the art of digital preservation in three ways: by developing infrastructure and tools for scalable preservation actions; by providing a framework for automated, quality-assured preservation workflows, and by integrating these components with a policy-based preservation planning and watch system. These concrete project results are being validated within three large-scale Testbeds from diverse application areas.
DPC - Digital Preservation Coalition – is an advocate and catalyst for digital preservation, with a vision of making our digital memory accessible tomorrow. Our target audience is varied: people who want to learn more about digital preservation; those already involved in digital preservation; and members of organisations which may be interested in discovering more about our research and advocacy. We can provide introductory information to participants, and advise on many issues relating to digital preservation.
The EU co-funded TIMBUS project TIMBUS - Timeless Business – addresses the challenge of digital preservation of business processes and services to ensure their long-term continued access. While the project focuses on industrial institutions, our services will feed back to the processes in memory institutions. Our target audience for this workshop is people with a particular interest in exploring the benefits of process preservation for their business. We can introduce them to the TIMBUS approach to process preservation and give advice on where they can find more information about process preservation including planning, risk management and legal aspects.
ForgetIT – While preservation of digital content is now well established in memory institutions such as national libraries and archives, it is still in its infancy in most other organizations, and even more so for personal content. ForgetIT combines three new concepts to ease the adoption of preservation in the personal and organizational context.
DURAARK -Durable Architectural Knowledge – is developing methods and tools for the Long-Term Preservation (LTP) of architectural knowledge, including approaches to enrich Building Information Models with “as built” information from scans, semantically enrich building models with additional data sets and preserve 3D models for future reuse.
OPF - Open Planets Foundation – addresses core digital preservation challenges by engaging with its members and the community to develop practical and sustainable tools and services to ensure long-term access to digital content.
SCIDIP-ES – Science Data Infrastructure for Preservation – Earth Science – The aim of the initiative is to deliver generic infrastructure services for science data preservation and to build on the experience of the ESA Earth Observation Long Term Data Preservation (LTDP) programme to favour the set-up of a European Framework for the long term preservation of Earth Science (ES) data through the definition of common preservation policies, the harmonization of metadata and semantics and the deployment of the generic infrastructure services in ES domain.
The ALEXANDRIA project aims to develop models, tools and techniques necessary to archive and index relevant parts of the Web, and to retrieve and explore this information in a meaningful way. While the easy accessibility to the current Web is a good baseline, optimal access to Web archives requires new models and algorithms for retrieval, exploration, and analytics which go far beyond what is needed to access the current state of the Web. This includes taking into account the unique temporal dimension of Web archives, structured semantic information already available on the Web, as well as social media and network information.
DCH-RP - Digital Cultural Heritage Roadmap for Preservation – is a Coordination Action supported by the European Commission under the FP7 e-Infrastructure Capacities Programme, to design a Roadmap for the implementation of a federated e-Infrastructure for the long-term preservation of DCH content. The Roadmap will be supplemented by practical tools for decision makers and validated through a range of proofs of concept, where cultural institutions and e-Infrastructure providers work together on concrete experiments.
EUDAT - European Data Infrastructure -is laying the foundations for a European Collaborative Data Infrastructure. EUDAT takes a service-oriented approach to federating existing European research data repositories, paving the way for common approaches to data sharing, data archiving, data finding and data re-use for European research.
rss – research & service support – “The RSS Service aims to support EO communities to exploit EO data, researchers and service providers to develop applications, promotion of ground segment harmonisation activities and management of EO data. In the framework of the RSS activity the New Model for Exploitation of Digitally Preserved Data aims to design a federated environment for a) Facilitating the exploitation of data, b) Improving the overall missions operability, reliability, availability, c) Reducing cost, d) Ensuring preservation/access of data and information in the long term, e) Leveraging technological evolution and competences developed in European scientific centres f) Using European products, g) Standardised interfaces.
RSS is part of ESA’s Earth Observation Ground Segment Department.
Daria Sas (Luleå University of Technology)
John Lindström (Luleå University of Technology)
Michela Vignoli (Austrian Institute of Technology)
Rebecca McGuinness (Open Planets Foundation)
Melanie Imming (National Library of the Netherlands)
Kresimir Duretec (Vienna University of Technology)
Andreas Rauber (Vienna University of Technology)
Jette G. Junge (State and University Library, Denmark)
It is a critical time in the process of setting up the APA Centre of Excellence for Digital Preservation, the culmination of more than 5 years’ work, and so it seems the right time to write a post about it.
The APA’s strategic plan laid out a roadmap for its expansion. This was to be achieved largely through EU projects. Preliminary work was done through CASPAR, PARSE.Insight and ODE. Their results (their deliverables are on the APA site) are being carried forward in the two projects I would focus on here.
The first of these projects is APARSEN, a network of excellence with more than 30 partners; its aim is to integrate the various, often inconsistent, strands of research in digital preservation, and to help create the Centre of Excellence. It’s website is part of the APA’s site. The second, complementary, project is SCIDIP-ES. This is creating a set of services which can supplement the digital preservation capabilities of existing repositories, bringing them nearer to the level required for a successful ISO16363 audit. The SCIDIP-ES website is separate from the APA’s at the moment but the software is being handed over to the APA right now.
At the time the strategic plan was drawn up one of the aims was to move beyond digital preservation research into industrial strength digital preservation and even beyond that. By this I mean that the value of our digital capital was of course recognised already but the demand for increasing value was also growing. If, following OAIS, digital preservation is defined as maintaining the understandability and usability of digital objects by a specified community, then there is a natural extension towards enabling the digital object to be used by a broader community i.e. to be more usable by more people, thereby becoming more valuable.
What was not really anticipated was that EU funding for “blue-sky” digital preservation research would essentially come to an end. On the other hand since more than 100M Euros has been invested by the EU in digital preservation research it might have been expected that payback would be expected.
The question “who pays for digital preservation and why?” was increasingly heard, and there were insufficient answers. Studies such as that of the Blue Ribbon Task Force suggested ways to look at the issue. The Riding the Wave report , to which I contributed, recognised the issue but did not address it.
This has encouraged APARSEN to produce an integrated view of digital preservation within a business process. A key aspect of this is provided by SCIDIP-ES because that project has created tools and services which add to value through increased usability.
It has taken several years to put all these pieces in place. APARSEN has investigated many of the silos of digital preservation research, collecting, evaluating and integrating the many isolated pieces of research – research which used different terminology, concepts and approaches. SCIDIP-ES has created a solid collection of customisable software tools and services. In additional the ISO16363 has been created, by myself and the PTAB team, and may provide the basis for a real market for digital preservation.
Over the next several months the things which the Centre of Excellence will offer will be put in place including training, software services, tools and consultancy. These will be provided from the outcomes of the projects as well as by APA members.
It is certainly going to be an interesting time.
The workshop consists of a number of outcomes of the APARSEN project. APARSEN is a European project that runs until the end of this year, aimed at the establishment of a Virtual Centre of Excellence on digital preservation. The project partners gathered expertise on a wide range of digital preservation issues clustered in four topics: (1) Trust, (2) Sustainability, (3) Accessibility, and (4) Usability. The workshop is focused on the last two topics covered in the APARSEN project. The most important outcomes of the work done in the project are presented and discussed in the workshop.
The usability aspect of digital preservation is covered by a presentation on interoperability and intelligibility. The focus in this presentation will be on solutions for semantic interoperability in order to keep data understandable and processable in the long run.
The accessibility aspect of digital preservation is covered by three presentations. The first contribution concerns the importance of persistent identifiers to provide durable access to digital objects. More specifically in this presentation attention is paid to an interoperability framework that enables seamless access to digital objects that have two or more persistent identifiers. Two other contributions in the access topic concern an analysis of digital rights and access management of digital objects and a presentation on policy issues relevant for digital preservation. Both presentations pay attention to the outcomes of a survey carried out in the framework done in the APARSEN project.
Duration: 09:00 – 12:30; 2 July 2014
Each presentation takes 40 minutes and includes at least 15 minutes for discussion.
09:00-09:10 Introduction on the workshop. Background on the APARSEN project and context of the topics covered in the workshop
Download: LIBER 2014 – Workshop on Usability and Accessibility and Aspects of Digital Preservation
09:10-09:50 Interoperability and Intelligibility (Yannis Kargakis, Forth, Greece)
Download: LIBER 2014: Interoperability and Intelligibility
09:50-10:30 Persistent identifiers (Maurizio Lunghi, FRD, Italy)
Download: LIBER 2014: Persistent Identifiers
10:30-11:00 Coffee break
11:00-11:40 Digital rights and access management (Stefan Hein, DNB, Germany)
Download: LIBER 2014: Digital rights and access management
11:40-12:20 Data policies and governance (Juha Lehtonen, CSC, Finland)
Download: LIBER 2014: Data Policies (and Governance)
12:20-12:30 Wrap-up and conclusions
Prof. Paolo Bouquet, Trento, Italy
Paolo Bouquet, is professor of computer science at the Management School of the University of Trento (Italy). In addition to his substantial academic record, he has been successfully creating and leading large, publicly funded research projects, including FP/ Integrated Project OKKAM – Enabling the Web of Entities. Paolo is one of the initiators of the open data initiative in the Trentino Region (“Trentino Open Data”). Paolo is Chairman of the Board and co-founder of OKKAM s.r.l. In such a role, Paolo has led projects in the areas of tax collection, public transportation systems, data integration, and tourism.
Paolo was the Director of the DIGOIDUNA Study, an EC report on “Digital Object Identifiers and Unique Authors Identifiers to enable services for data quality assessment, provenance and access”, which is currently a key document in the H2020 strategy in the area of Persistent Identifiers for e-Infrastructures.
Yannis Kargakis, Forth, Greece
Yannis Kargakis is currently a Research & Development Engineer in Information Systems Lab at FORTH-ICS (Greece). He conducted his undergraduate and graduate studies (MSc) in the Computer Science Department at University of Crete. His research interests fall in the following areas: Information Systems, Digital Preservation, Semantic Web, and Dependency Management Reasoning. He has participated in the research projects: APARSEN NoE and SCIDIP-ES.
Maurizio Lunghi, FRD, Italy
Maurizio Lunghi has a degree in Electronic Engineering, Telecommunications and Telematics – Internet technology and networking. He has experience of working with international projects funded by the European Commission where he has worked for 3 years as project officer in the DG INFSO in Luxembourg. Organization of events and coordination of expert groups are very common in his experience. He has participated in research projects on networking and ICT, high resolution imaging, telemedicine applications, on digital libraries and digital preservation related issues. From 2010 he is involved in the APARSERN project. His interest and activity lie in the area of persistent identifiers systems, trusted digital repositories criteria, audit and certification.
Stefan Hein, DNB, Germany
Stefan Hein is a Software Developer in the context of processing digital objects and their Digital Preservation at the DNB since 2010. He graduated with a Diploma in Computer Science at the Humboldt University at Berlin. The current main focus of his work is the further development of the ingest workflow for example with capabilities for validating and identifying digital objects and their long term preservation.
Juha Lehtonen, CSC, Finland
Dr. Juha Lehtonen works as an Applications Architect in CSC – IT Center for Science, Finland. He joined CSC in 2012 to create digital preservation solutions for cultural heritage of Finland, and he is also involved in APARSEN. In 2009-2012 he was founding a digitization center for natural history collections of Finland, where he was planning and implementing the technical side of the digitization processes. In 2005-2009 he worked as a researcher in the University of Joensuu until he received his Ph.D. in Computer Science.
APARSEN/SCAPE Project Satellite Event – Long term accessibility of digital resources in theory and practice
Vienna, Austria – 21st Mai 2014
It took place in the context of the 3rd LIBER Workshop on Digital Curation “Keeping data: The process of data curation” (19-20 May 2014)
An overview on management aspects such as digital rights management, policies and costs as well as technical aspects with a focus on preservation planning and scalability in digital preservation will be given. Insights into the day-to-day practice of digital preservation will foster the understanding of theoretical concepts developed in the two EU funded projects.
The programme was as follows:
09:00 – 10:30
- Sabine Schrimpf (German National Library): Digital Rights Management in the context of long-term preservation
- Ross King (Austrian Institute of Technology): The SCAPE Project and Scalable Quality Control - Ross King
- David Wang (SBA Research): Understanding the Costs of Digital Curation - David Wang
11:00 – 12:30
- Sven Schlarb (Austrian National Library): Application scenarios of the SCAPE project at the Austrian National Library - Sven Schlarb
- Krešimir Đuretec (Vienna University of Technology): SCAPE Preservation Planning and Watch - Kresimir Duretec
- Ruben Riestra (INMARK): Answering Key Questions - Ruben Riestra
Austrian National Library
If you were not able to make it to the conference in New Delhi you can still it all!
The videos, presentations, discussions and papers are all available here
From Juan Bicarregui (STFC):
The link below leads to this week’s statement by G8 ministers on “international issues that require global cooperation”.
The four topics discussed were:
- global challenges
- global research infrastructure
- open scientific research data
- increasing access to the peer-reviewed, published results of scientific research
The third and fourth topics will be of particular interest to APA and APARSEN members.
Interoperability of Persistent Identifiers Systems – services across PI domains
Date: Thursday, 5th September 2013, afternoon
Location: IST – Instituto Superior Técnico in Lisbon, Portugal
Maurizio Lunghi e Emanuele Bellini (Fondazione Rinascimento Digitale/APARSEN), Renè Van Horik (DANS), Barbara Bazzanella e Paolo Bouquet (UNITN), Bas Cordewener (Knowledge Exchange), Anila Angjeli (ISNI), Giovanni Bergamin (Central National Library in Florence), Norman Pasquin (LCC and DOI foundation), John Kunze (California Digital Library), Tobias Weigel (RDA), Antoine Isaac (Europeana), (NN, EUDAT)
The central goal of this second edition of the workshop on Interoperability of Persistent Identifier Systems (www.rinascimento-digitale.it/workshopPI2012) is to bring together representatives from different PI communities to discuss potential benefits for final users as well as challenges requirements and technologies to implement an effective interoperability solution for different PI systems and related services. Supporters of this workshop proposal and the experts in the programme committee represents large and significant PI user communities, other experts are
A first section is devoted to users and to potential services and benefits for final users that could be built on such an interoperability framework. Participants are involved in the description of future user scenarios and potential applications of the PI systems, making evident user benefits and requirements.
A second section is focused on technical aspects regarding the implementation of an interoperability solution and related services. As a starting point for the technical discussion, the new Interoperability Framework (IF) for PI systems, proposed by the APARSEN project and refined by a large group of independent experts is described and a demonstrator is presented. The IF model is suitable to all the different user requirements and is adoptable by all PI user communities.
Participants are invited to compare their requirements with the IF features and assumptions confronting on various aspects of the model, potential benefits and concrete terms for a common roadmap for the implementation of the framework in order to create consensus on to develop joint cross-domain applications.
Representatives of the most relevant PI initiatives and different PI user communities are invited to report on current activities and vision, but also on possible approaches to define interoperability solutions and services and expose their position towards needs and opportunities of moving toward the implementation of a comprehensive interoperability technological solution for PI systems.
Joint APARSEN/4C workshop:
What does it cost? – EU Activities to Assess the Cost of Digital Curation
Date: Thursday, 5th September 2013, afternoon
Location: IST – Instituto Superior Técnico in Lisbon, Portugal
Subject of the Workshop:
Digital preservation and curation activities tend to be costly and complex and require a long term commitment. Without reliable cost information and accurate cost models, it is hard to plan and calculate such activities seriously.
A number of digital curation cost models have been developed in the last years, and initiatives like Knowledge Exchange, the Digital Curation Centre, and the Blue Ribbon Task Force for Economically Sustainable Digital Curation have, among others, looked at cost and benefits of keeping digital data available for the long term. Most recently, the APARSEN project has provided a high level analysis of published cost models, it has reviewed cost parameters in relation to the trusted digital repositories standard, ISO 16363, and it has investigated the level of preparedness of research libraries to ensure economically-sustainable digital preservation.
The new EU project 4C – ‘the Collaboration to Clarify the Costs of Curation’ – draws all of these initiatives and their results together. It networks existing projects and initiatives and will ensure that where existing work is relevant, stakeholders realize it and understand how to employ it. A key aim for this workshop is to build bridges between ongoing costs-related initiatives to enable 4C to identify areas where good progress has been made and also to understand how current cost models might be augmented to improve ease of use and increase uptake. Ultimately, 4C will help organizations to approach their investment in data curation and preservation with greater certainty and with greater clarity about what they will get back in return. The project partners will use the workshop as an opportunity to set the scene for their topic, present their approach (“assess, enhance, engage”) and invite feedback of workshop participants.
A key point for the open discussion session will be to identify difficulties that ongoing costs-related initiatives have had in collecting cost information and encouraging use of their models. During the session we will invite input from these initiatives into how 4C might help to overcome these difficulties to realise increased uptake of the models and ultimately an improved understanding of curation costs.
Veronika Prändl-Zika, Austrian National Library, presented the APARSEN project in the course of the Metaday #59 at the Metalab in Vienna on June 7, 2013. For more details: https://metalab.at/wiki/Metaday_59
Organised by IEDA and Elsevier Research Data Services, the International Data Rescue Award in the Geosciences is created to improve preservation and access of research data, particularly of dark data, and share the varied ways that these data are being processed, stored, and used. For more information see http://researchdata.elsevier.com/datachallenge
The organisers are interested in receiving submissions from groups who have developed and completed projects that have digitized previously unavailable content or that have facilitated and improved the ingestion of research data. The final submission deadline is October 10, 2013.